Skip to content

Europe · Analysis

Independent · Brussels & Berlin

World · European security

Germany, Poland and France pledge NATO unity as Zelenskyy urges joint air shield

German foreign minister Johann Wadephul says no alliance member will face Russian provocations alone, while Ukraine's president proposes a shared aerial defence system at Warsaw Security Forum.

By , Security and Defence Editor

Published

11 min read

German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul stood alongside his Polish and French counterparts in Warsaw on Monday and delivered the clearest statement yet from Europe's three largest NATO powers: the alliance will not fracture under Russian pressure. "NATO would protect every inch of our alliance territory, no member state is left alone to deal with these threats," he said at a press conference with Radoslaw Sikorski and Jean-Noel Barrot. The declaration came in response to a string of Russian drone incursions into NATO airspace, including incidents over Poland and Denmark that have tested the alliance's collective resolve.

A coordinated European front takes shape in Warsaw

The trilateral meeting was not ceremonial. Wadephul, Sikorski and Barrot gathered at the Warsaw Security Forum, an annual gathering that has become the primary venue for European defence coordination since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Their joint appearance signalled a deliberate effort to present a unified position before the wider NATO membership. Wadephul described Moscow's actions as a test of Western resolve: "Russia wants to test our resolve and to stir unrest. That is dangerous and must be answered clearly and with unity." He added that Germany was "standing together, keeping a cool head and not allowing ourselves to be driven into an escalation."

The language was carefully calibrated. Neither Wadephul nor his counterparts invoked Article 5, the collective defence clause that treats an attack on one member as an attack on all. Instead they emphasised "clarity, unity, resolve, and prudence", the same formulation used by Defence Minister Boris Pistorius in his own address to the forum. Pistorius warned that President Vladimir Putin "deliberately attempts to undermine European security and the territorial integrity of European nations" and "seeks to provoke NATO member states" to "expose vulnerabilities within our alliance." The German defence minister was explicit: "We will not be lured into Putin's trap of continuous escalation."

Zelenskyy offers a practical alternative: a joint air shield

While the NATO ministers spoke of deterrence, Ukraine's president offered a concrete operational proposal. Addressing the same forum by video link, Volodymyr Zelenskyy called for a "joint fully reliable shield against Russian aerial threats" linking Ukraine with Poland and other European partners. "Ukraine can counter all kinds of Russian drones and missiles and if we act together in the region we will have enough weapons and production capacity," he said. The proposal reflects a shift in Ukrainian thinking: after more than three years of war, Kyiv has developed extensive experience in intercepting Russian drones and missiles, and its domestic defence industry has expanded significantly.

Zelenskyy's pitch is both military and industrial. Ukraine's air defence units have intercepted thousands of Russian drones and missiles since 2022, developing tactics and integration procedures that NATO members are still learning. At the same time, Ukrainian defence companies, often working in partnership with European firms, have ramped up production of electronic warfare systems, mobile air defence platforms and drone interceptors. A regional shield would pool these capabilities with Polish, Romanian and Baltic air defence networks, potentially creating a layered system stretching from the Black Sea to the Arctic.

Russia's military machine keeps expanding

The European coordination comes as Moscow continues to build its manpower. On the same day, Putin signed a decree ordering the autumn conscription of 135,000 men aged between 18 and 30, the largest autumn draft since 2016. The conscripts are officially designated for one-year service at military bases inside Russia and are not supposed to be deployed to Ukraine. In practice, however, conscripts who complete basic training enter the reserve pool from which the Kremlin draws contract soldiers and mobilised personnel. Russian officials maintain the annual conscription cycle is unrelated to the partial mobilisation announced in September 2022, but the distinction has blurred as the war enters its fourth year.

The scale of the draft matters. Russia's armed forces have suffered heavy casualties in Ukraine, Western estimates suggest 600,000 to 800,000 killed and wounded since February 2022, and the Kremlin has avoided a second general mobilisation for domestic political reasons. Instead it has relied on high signing bonuses, prison recruitment drives and steady conscription flows to replenish units. The 135,000 figure represents a 20% increase over the autumn 2024 draft of 113,000, indicating the General Staff expects manpower demands to grow.

Escalation on both sides of the border

The drone war intensified over the weekend. Russian air defences reported intercepting 78 Ukrainian drones overnight, most over the border regions of Bryansk and Belgorod. In the Moscow region, governor Andrei Vorobyov said two people, a 76-year-old woman and her six-year-old grandson, died when a downed drone caused a house fire in Voskresensk. The attack followed a massive Russian barrage the previous night involving nearly 600 drones and 48 missiles against Ukrainian targets, most of which Kyiv said were shot down.

These reciprocal strikes have become a nightly routine. Ukraine's long-range drone programme has systematically targeted Russian oil refineries, airfields and logistics hubs deep inside Russian territory, while Moscow's combined missile and drone campaigns aim to degrade Ukrainian energy infrastructure and air defences ahead of winter. Neither side has achieved strategic surprise in months; the conflict has settled into a war of attrition where air defence capacity and production depth determine outcomes.

Moscow raises the nuclear rhetoric again

Former president Dmitry Medvedev, now deputy chairman of Russia's Security Council, accompanied the military escalation with a familiar threat. Writing on Telegram, he warned that any war with Europe "has an absolutely real risk of escalating into a war using weapons of mass destruction." "They simply cannot afford a war with Russia," he said of European powers, adding that "the possibility of a fatal accident always exists." The language mirrors statements Medvedev has made repeatedly since 2022, serving as a deliberate signal to Western capitals that the Kremlin considers the conflict existential and will not rule out nuclear use if its core interests are threatened.

Western officials treat such statements as psychological warfare rather than operational signalling. NATO's nuclear planning group has not altered its posture, and the alliance's 2022 Strategic Concept already identifies Russia as the most significant and direct threat to allies' security. But the repetition of nuclear threats serves a purpose: it complicates European public debate over long-range weapons deliveries to Ukraine and reinforces the caution that has characterised German policy in particular.

Russia exits the European anti-torture convention

In a move that attracted less attention but carries legal weight, Putin signed a law withdrawing Russia from the European Convention for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment. The convention, administered by the Council of Europe's Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT), grants monitors the right to visit places of detention without prior notice. Russia's Foreign Ministry claimed the withdrawal would not "harm" Russian citizens and that Moscow "remains committed to its international human-rights obligations." Two UN special rapporteurs disagreed, saying the move "raises red flags about what is going on behind bars" in Russian jails.

The withdrawal follows years of CPT reports documenting systemic abuse in Russian prisons and pre-trial detention centres, including the treatment of political prisoners such as Alexei Navalny, who died in an Arctic penal colony in February 2024. Russia was expelled from the Council of Europe in March 2022 after the invasion of Ukraine but remained a party to several conventions. The torture convention exit completes its disengagement from the European human rights architecture.

Hungary and Ukraine escalate an information war

A different kind of confrontation unfolded between Kyiv and Budapest. Hungary blocked access to 12 Ukrainian news websites, including European Pravda, a outlet that closely tracks Ukraine's EU accession process and Hungarian efforts to obstruct it. Prime Minister Viktor Orban's chief of staff, Gergely Gulyas, called it "a proportional response to an entirely unjustified attack" after Ukraine restricted eight Hungarian-language portals deemed to carry pro-Russian narratives, among them the popular government-aligned site origo.hu. The tit-for-tat marks a further deterioration in relations that have been strained since 2022, when Orban maintained close ties with Putin and opposed EU military aid to Kyiv.

The dispute reflects a deeper structural problem: Hungary's veto power over EU decisions on Ukraine, from sanctions packages to accession negotiations, gives Orban leverage disproportionate to his country's size. Kyiv's website restrictions were implemented at the request of Ukrainian security services, which argued the Hungarian portals amplified Russian disinformation. Budapest frames its retaliation as defence of media freedom. Neither side appears willing to de-escalate, and the episode will complicate the next EU summit where Ukraine's membership talks are on the agenda.

Moldova delivers a pro-European verdict

Amid the war's grim calculus, a democratic bright spot emerged in Chișinău. Moldova's ruling Party of Action and Solidarity (PAS) won Sunday's parliamentary election with more than half the vote, according to near-complete results. President of the European Council Antonio Costa declared that "the people of Moldova have spoken and their message is loud and clear. They chose democracy, reform and a European future, in the face of pressure and interference from Russia." Commission President Ursula von der Leyen echoed the sentiment: "No attempt to sow fear or division could break your resolve."

The election was widely seen as a referendum on Moldova's EU path after the country secured candidate status in June 2022 and opened accession negotiations in December 2023. Russian interference, including vote-buying schemes, disinformation campaigns and the channelling of funds through the fugitive oligarch Ilan Shor, was documented by Moldovan intelligence and Western observers. PAS's outright majority gives President Maia Sandu a mandate to pursue reforms required for membership, though the Kremlin will almost certainly continue efforts to destabilise the government.

Germany's permanent brigade in Lithuania takes shape

Beyond declarations, Germany is putting troops on the ground. Pistorius travelled from Warsaw to Lithuania, where the Bundeswehr is deploying a combat brigade, roughly 4,800 soldiers and 200 civilian personnel, as part of NATO's enhanced forward presence on the eastern flank. The brigade is expected to reach full operational capability by 2027. It represents Germany's first permanent overseas combat deployment since the end of the Cold War and a significant shift for a country that has historically resisted stationing heavy forces abroad.

The Lithuanian deployment is the concrete expression of the "clarity, unity, resolve" Pistorius invoked in Warsaw. It also answers a long-standing demand from Baltic and Polish allies for a credible European conventional deterrent. The brigade will be equipped with Leopard 2 tanks, Puma infantry fighting vehicles and Boxer armoured personnel carriers, supported by artillery and air defence assets. Its presence changes the calculus for any Russian planner contemplating a test of Article 5: a German-led formation would be engaged from day one.

Sources

  1. dw.com

    dw.com · 2025-09-29

People mentioned

  • Johann Wadephul

    Foreign Minister of Germany, German Federal Foreign Office

  • Boris Pistorius

    Defence Minister of Germany, German Federal Ministry of Defence

  • Volodymyr Zelenskyy

    President of Ukraine, Presidential Office of Ukraine

  • Radoslaw Sikorski

    Foreign Minister of Poland, Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs

  • Jean-Noel Barrot

    Foreign Minister of France, French Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs

  • Vladimir Putin

    President of Russia, Russian Federation

  • Dmitry Medvedev

    Deputy Chairman of Russia's Security Council, Security Council of the Russian Federation

  • Antonio Costa

    President of the European Council, European Council

Organisations

NATO · European Union · German Federal Foreign Office · German Federal Ministry of Defence · Polish Ministry of Foreign Affairs · French Ministry for Europe and Foreign Affairs

Related analysis

Selected because they share topics with this article

The newsletter

One important European story. Explained properly.

Delivered to your inbox on the days we publish. No daily digest, no push notifications, no advertising.

We store your address only to send the briefing. Unsubscribe in one click.